Metal or wood, which one should you choose for your next building project? It’s a common question, especially when you’re investing in something meant to last. Whether you’re planning a garage, barn, or backyard workshop, the material you pick will affect everything from cost to durability to long-term maintenance.
This article cuts through the noise. You’ll get a clear, side-by-side breakdown of metal and wood buildings, what they cost, how long they last, and which is better suited to your goals. If you’re weighing your options, this guide will help you make the smart call.
Cost Comparison
Initial Investment
- Metal buildings (e.g., pre-engineered steel kits) typically start at $25–30 per sq ft for the shell and framing .
- Wood structures, such as pole barns or traditional framing, range from $25–100 per sq ft depending on design complexity .
So, while wood can be cheaper on the surface, fully finished wood buildings often end up costing more.
Labor & Construction Time
- Steel kits arrive mostly pre-cut and numbered, reducing labor and speeding up assembly. Contractors estimate erection can be up to 66% faster than wood framing.
- Wood framing requires more time and finishing (insulation, trim, drywall), which increases labor costs .
Long‑Term Maintenance
- Steel buildings need minimal upkeep, occasional cleaning and fastener checks. Paint for steel often lasts decades.
- Wood buildings require repainting every 3–7 years, pest treatment, and occasional rot repair. Over 20–30 years, wood needs 7–10 major interventions, compared to just 2–3 for steel
Annual Cost Outlook
For a 10,000 sq ft structure:
- Steel maintenance costs about 1% of initial cost (~$1,500–2,500/year).
- Wood costs around 2–4% ($7,000–20,000/year) due to paints, repairs, pest control.
Insurance & Energy Savings
- Metal buildings often qualify for lower insurance premiums because they resist fire, pests, and extreme weather.
- Insulated steel buildings can also reduce energy bills by 10–20% yearly, saving $2,000–5,000 on a mid-size structure
While wood buildings may seem more affordable at the start, the total cost of ownership often tells a different story. Once you account for maintenance, labor, insurance, and energy use, metal buildings tend to offer better long-term value for most projects.
Durability and Longevity
When it comes to how long a building lasts and how well it stands up to everyday wear, metal buildings offer clear advantages over wood:
- Resistance to rot, pests, and moisture: Steel is immune to termites, fungi, mold, warping, and rot common issues in wooden buildings. Wood requires regular treatments and monitoring to prevent moisture damage.
- Superior performance in harsh weather: Metal buildings withstand extreme conditions ( heavy snow, strong winds) even seismic activity better than wood, thanks to their strength and uniform structure .
- Long lifespan: Well-maintained steel structures can last 50–100+ years. Wood buildings typically need significant renovations after 20–30 years and often don’t reach the century mark.
- Low structural degradation: Unlike wood, which swells, shrinks, or cracks with seasonal humidity changes, steel maintains its shape and strength over decades.
- Fire protection: Steel is non-combustible and acts as a barrier to flames, while wood is highly flammable which increases fire insurance costs and risk.
Metal buildings offer a lifespan and resilience that significantly outpace wood. If you want to minimize worry about rot, pests, fire, or shifting foundations, steel is the clear choice. And this long-term durability translates to savings and fewer maintenance headaches over the years.
Maintenance Requirements
When it comes to upkeep, metal and wood buildings couldn’t be more different:
Steel Structures: Easy Maintenance
Metal buildings require very little attention, usually just a rinse and clean once or twice a year, plus checking fasteners and repainting only if coatings wear off. Over 30 years, average annual maintenance may be as low as $200–$500 for moderate-sized steel buildings .
Wood Buildings: Ongoing Upkeep
Wood needs much more care:
- Staining or painting every 2–7 years to prevent moisture damage and UV wear.
- Regular pest prevention spraying insecticide around foundations, treating termites and carpenter ants .
- Keeping gutters clear and ensuring siding stays dry.
- On average, expect to spend $2,000–$4,000 per year on maintenance including painting, pest control, and repairs.
Visual Example of Upkeep Gap
According to experts, steel buildings might need just 2–3 major interventions over their lifespan. By contrast, wood structures typically require 7–10 such efforts like repainting, resealing, or pest treatments.
Why This Matters
- Time & Effort: Steel saves you hours each year, no scraping paint or fighting bugs.
- Budget Control: Few surprises with metal; wood upkeep can suddenly balloon with rot or termite damage.
- Building Value: Well-maintained metal buildings retain their look and functionality longer than wood.
Aesthetics & Design Flexibility
Design choices often come down to not just function, but feel. Here’s how wood and metal compare:
Natural Warmth vs. Modern Simplicity
- Wood buildings exude a timeless warmth and a “homey” appeal that people naturally connect with. Their exposed beams, varied textures, and rich grain give an inviting and cozy atmosphere.
- Metal structures bring a sleek, modern vibe. Thanks to finishes that mimic wood or can be clad in other materials (brick, wood trim), you can achieve unique blends of contemporary and classic looks .
Customization & Interior Space
- Steel’s high strength-to-weight ratio allows for wider clear-spans and open plans without interior columns. This creates flexible, spacious interiors ideal for workshops, studios, or barns.
- Wood is more forgiving if you want to alter your design mid-build. It’s easy to cut, modify, and add details. This makes it a favorite for custom homes and renovations.
Hybrid Builds Best of Both Worlds
Some owners choose a hybrid approach: a sturdy steel frame for the structure, combined with wood for aesthetic elements (e.g., exterior siding or interior finish). This offers the durability of metal with the charm of natural wood .
Visual Longevity
Wood ages gracefully weathered and warm but can fade or warp without upkeep .
Metal finishes well over time. Coated steel panels resist fading, and newer wood-look technologies maintain their appearance far longer .
Environmental Considerations
When you choose between metal and wood, you’re not just picking a building material, you’re making a decision that impacts the planet.
Carbon Emissions & Embodied Energy
- Wood, especially mass timber or engineered wood, offers a lower carbon footprint. It absorbs CO₂ during growth and stores carbon for decades. Studies show timber buildings can have 30–40% less embodied carbon compared to steel counterparts .
- Steel fabrication is energy-intensive, producing more greenhouse gases upfront. But because steel lasts longer and is reusable, it can offset these emissions over time
Lifecycle Environmental Impact
- A mass timber structure can save about 19% in CO₂ emissions compared to a steel version of the same size.
- However, a comprehensive study found wood uses 28–47% less embodied energy than steel when factoring in extraction, transport, and manufacturing.
Recyclability & Reuse
- Steel is fully recyclable and can be repeatedly melted and reused without losing strength. It meets LEED environmental standards.
- Wood, especially when sustainably sourced, is renewable. Reclaimed timber can be reused or made into panels, reducing waste .
Energy Efficiency in Use
- Steel buildings, when well-insulated, can be very efficient reducing heating and cooling costs and emissions over the life of the building .
- Wood is a natural insulator, improving thermal performance and reducing the need for heating and cooling often by 10–30% versus steel .
Takeaway
- If your priority is long-term carbon storage and low upfront emissions, wood (especially mass timber) is a strong choice.
- If you value recyclability, durability, and meeting green building standards, steel may be more aligned with your goals.
- A hybrid approach using steel structure with wood elements can offer an eco-friendly balance.
Speed & Ease of Construction
Time is money and when it comes to building, every day counts. That’s where steel structures often shine over wood.
- Significantly faster assembly: Prefabricated steel panels are fabricated off-site and arrive ready to be assembled. This method can cut framing time by about 30–33% compared to traditional wood builds.
- Quicker site setup: For smaller projects like garages or sheds, steel buildings can be erected in as little as a few days to a week, while larger structures finish in 2–4 weeks. Complex commercial builds may wrap in just 1–3 months.
- Lean on weather-resistant scheduling: Offsite fabrication means most work happens in factories not on your site. That limits weather delays and lets crews prep foundations while panels are being made .
- Efficient use of labor: Prefab steel builds require fewer trades on-site. A small team can erect large metal frames quickly similar to snap-together models, but on a full-scale building .
By contrast, wood framing is slower. Cure times for treated lumber, weather volatility, and on-site cutting and fitting all add time and labor cost to your build.
Insurance & Resale Value
Lower Insurance Premiums
Canadian developers and homeowners see significant savings on insurance when opting for steel over wood.
- Steel framing is classified as non-combustible under insurance standards, directly lowering builder’s risk and property insurance rates.
- In real-world examples, premiums for steel buildings in Canada can be up to 75% lower compared to wood-framed structures
Resale Impact & ROI
Steel buildings not only lower costs they also elevate property appeal in the Canadian market.
- Ontario contractors report that steel structures provide faster ROI due to shorter construction time, reduced upkeep, and buyer preference.
- Adding a steel garage or workshop may increase home value by around 13%, supported by North American studies.
Over two decades, commercial steel buildings maintain 70–80% of their value, compared to about 60–70% for wood, enhancing both resale and investment stability .
Common Use Cases
Agricultural and Farm Buildings
In Canada, pre‑engineered steel buildings are rapidly gaining popularity on farms. They offer superior protection from harsh weather, pests, and decay vital for structures like barns, riding arenas, equipment storage, and workshops.
Commercial & Industrial Spaces
Steel structures dominate in warehouses, manufacturing facilities, and retail outlets. Their clear‑span design allows open interiors with no obstructive columns ideal for heavy machinery, large inventory, or flexible workspace needs .
Garages, Workshops & Hobby Spaces
Homeowners prefer steel for garages and personal workshops. These buildings go up fast, resist rust, rot, and pests, and maintain structural integrity even in extreme seasons .
Residential and Hybrid Homes
Steel framing is becoming more common in homes, especially those combining wood interiors with steel skeletons. These hybrids offer timber’s warmth inside and steel’s durability outside .
Public, Recreational & Specialty Structures
Wood, especially mass timber and glulam, is still preferred for large public and recreational spaces like gyms, stadiums, arenas, and community halls. Its clear‑span capability and warm aesthetics shine in venues such as the Richmond Olympic Oval in BC .
Final Take
In the end, the choice between metal and wood buildings comes down to your long-term priorities. If you’re looking for durability, minimal maintenance, and protection against fire, pests, and harsh weather, a steel structure is often the smarter investment.
On the other hand, if natural aesthetics, carbon storage, and environmental sourcing are important to you, wood, especially engineered timber offers unique advantages. For many, a hybrid approach delivers the best of both worlds: the strength and lifespan of steel with the warmth and charm of wood finishes. Whatever your goal, making the right material choice upfront can save you time, money, and unexpected stress over the life of your building.
Ready to build smart? At Metal Pro™ Buildings, we specialize in durable, high-quality steel structures designed to suit your needs whether it’s a garage, barn, workshop, or commercial space. Get expert guidance, fast delivery across Canada, and competitive pricing backed by years of industry experience.
Request a Free Quote Now and let’s bring your project to life with confidence.
FAQ
